If a person believes in a higher being who created all this, they are forced to believe that He is entirely good or entirely evil. There is no in-between.
If a higher being created us without purpose or a plan for life after our time on earth as the Bible and Christianity teach, then life is nothing more than a cruel joke. We live, we die, and there is no point to any of it. Why would a creator do that unless they were entirely evil? Could there possibly be any good in them? Could a creator who put us on this planet to deal with all the frustrations of life (disease, hatred, murder, orphans, drugs, rape, wars, etc...) and no plan to ever do anything about it, be anything but evil? He either has a plan to fix things and get us out of this mess, or He doesn't. If He has a plan to help, He must at the very least be good. If He doesn't have a plan, it certainly brings into question His character to say the least.
Is it possible that the creator of all things could be kind of good AND kind of bad? Does He have good days and bad days? Does He love us some days but is grumpy and vengeful the next? Is the one who created and is in control of everything in fact unable to control Himself?
See, I think a lot of people that believe in a higher power aren't really convinced that He's all that good. Even those who know better and profess He's good still don't act like He's good all the time. I think people think He's moody. They've seen too much evil in this world to believe He could possibly be entirely good. But you can't ride the fencepost on this one folks.
As bad as things seem here on planet earth, it's far from lacking anything good, right? The creator gave us incredible qualities such as love, beauty and music. We may have different ideas of what they look like, but no one can deny that these qualities exist in each of us. And if you believe in a higher being, then you must believe that we only have these qualities because the creator put them in us. The only motive for doing such a thing would be out of love for His creation (us). Why else would He give us such amazing gifts? Would a creator give us the majestic mountains and the ability to appreciate their breath-taking beauty...just to be mean? Really? Just so we could have some joy on this planet in the middle of His evil scheme? And what about music? Is He just toying with us? Oh, and He instilled in us a sense of right and wrong...why? Every culture around the world that has ever existed believes that cold-blooded murder is wrong. Why did He give us all a sense of morality if morality doesn't matter?
You may ask, "Okay Mr. Smarty Pants...If He's so good and does have a plan to get us out of this mess, why would He have not simply made everything perfect and keep it that way?" Heaven, in other words. Why didn't the creator just make "heaven" and not mess with "earth?" Why would God make us endure the hardships and unfairness of life if He is so good and loving? This is where most people fall. they assume He must not be all that good after-all. They just don't get it. It's the most common argument against Him - "Why do bad things happen to good people if God is so good and loving?" It seems like such a logical question, right? But it assumes that if bad things happen to us which God allows, He cannot possibly still be good. Really? I mean, if God doesn't have a plan to fix things, then yeah, how could He be good? In fact, as I've already said, I think He'd be downright evil. It's just mean. But if He DOES in fact have a plan to fix things, then isn't it just possible that we're not seeing the big picture and that maybe, just maybe there's a reason He's allowing these things?
The fact that we don't understand why has no bearing on this truth and does not mean that the creator is evil. That's quite a leap in logic. If He created everything, then it stands to reason that He knows more than us and that we only feel it is "unfair" because we can't see and know everything like He can.
I mean, really. Does it sound even semi-logical to think that this is a God who's messing with us in some sick, twisted game He's playing...by Himself...for not apparent reason other than to be mean? Does that even remotely feel right?
And consider the fact that evil cannot exist without good. Evil is the absence of good. To say there is evil is to admit there is also good. A "good" God can allow evil to exist and still be good, so long as He has a plan to fix it. But an "evil" God would have no reason to allow good.
So how would a good creator who actually cares about us go about fixing things? Frankly, the story of the Bible is the only thing that makes sense (don't check out just yet!)
God created the world, including you and me, perfectly and out of love. He actually wanted us to genuinely love Him back (go figure), so He didn't force Himself on us or make us believe in Him, but He gave us a choice (hence, the tree in the Garden of Eden). Believe and follow, or not. It's our choice to make - God's not going to make it for us. But God knew, course, that most would not choose Him despite His deep desire that all would. That all of us would turn our backs on Him at some point and bring all the disorder and death and unfairness to into this world. And there HAS to be some kind of penalty for that. It's not the sort of thing you can just let go if you're the creator of the universe, no matter how much it pains you to do it and no matter how much you love your creation. The creation can't be allowed to walk all over the creator as if they're in charge.
And so before He even created the world, He planned on coming down Himself, living a sinless life and allowing Himself to be killed by His own creation only to raise back to life, therefore conquering death. In other words, He took death on for us. He beat it. He took the consequences of our turning our backs on Him off our shoulders where it belonged, and put it on His own so that the penalty that HAD to be paid was still paid. And we get to take on the sinless life that Jesus lived as if we were the ones who lived it. That's right. His perfect life becomes ours...if we want it.
And of course there's more! He didn't just save us from our sins so that we could walk around knowing we're saved from our sins. That's great and all, but we'd still live and die with no real point. But He's also promised a life beyond this one. A life that is truly perfect and will remain that way forever, because God will finally have a new world full of people who genuinely love Him without being forced.
That's why bad things happen to good people. They must. The story of the Bible and of Jesus is the only way any this is possible. There is NO other way for us to love God perfectly...the way He desires and deserves. There is NO way that is better for YOU in the long run. Can you think of another way God could accomplish this? Do you really think you have a better solution? Do you think He should not allow anything bad to happen to us? Are you mad at God? Do you think He's not such a good God after all?
Maybe it's just that you're not seeing the big picture.
God has a plan. It works. It makes sense. And, believe it or not, it's the best plan for you AND for Him even though it cost both you AND Him a great deal of pain.
So He's not just a good God. He's beyond words.
June 11, 2009 at 11:35 AM
Isn't there an element of Calvinistic "predetermination" in Christianity? I mean, I discussed this with my group-- the story of Job and how God knew that Job would not rebuke His name. So, if omnipotent God knows already whether or not we'll be "saved" or be loyal to Him, doesn't that defeat the whole purpose of free will? That's not right for a creation who were created equally, for the majority to be cast into Hell, all because some where "predetermined" to go there. Also, the reigning religion in the US is not Christianity anymore. It's Hinduism, I believe. Are that many possibly virtueous people going to Hell... or does God already know that they will?
Plus, there's the "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God" idea. People have been forcing upon others the fear of God unto others to convince and control them for hundreds of years... think "The Crucible".
Plus, I was reading the website that you posted last time: "Why Doesn't God Heal Amputees". I have to say, it was an interesting read. I'm quite surprised that they used scripture to back up their findings.
June 11, 2009 at 1:26 PM
Ha! Love the name username! Made me laugh!
The three or four points you brought up are all things that would require a ton of space and time to respond to, so these answers will not be as thorough as I'd like.
I do not agree with the Calvanistic view of predestination (predetermination). That's not to say I don't believe in predestination - just in the definition that John Calvin gave it, which is what everyone seems to think of when the talk about predestination. This is a concept that has caused quite the controversy in churches for centuries. You're right...if God just picks for us, and how we live our life or what we believe has nothing to do with it, it TOTALLY defeats the purpose free will. It makes no sense. I may as well say I don't believe any of it and spend my days murdering people or whatever else I want, because according to the idea of predestination, it wouldn't really matter because God decided long before I was born whether I'd go to heaven or hell and my beliefs and actions have nothing to do with it. If you look at the Scriptures that talk about this, you'll see two things. One is that some of them are just talking about the fact that God KNOWS ahead of time what we will choose - not that He chooses for us as some claim. The fact that God knows ahead of time changes nothing. It's still our choice. I would HOPE that God knows ahead of time, because if He didn't, He wouldn't really be God. The other verses that talk about this are not referring to a select few people, but to everybody. We have ALL been predestined "to be conformed to the likeness of his Son." (Romans 8:29). I mean, the overwhelming message of the whole Bible (and especially the New Testament)is that "God so loved the world that He gave his one and only Son, that WHOEVER believes in him shall not perish, but have eternal life." ANYONE can choose Him - He just knows who will before they do.
Not that it really matters, but here are the stats according to Wickapedia on religion in America: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_States
"Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God" was a sermon given by a preacher precisely to scare his congregation into submitting to God. It's intense to say the least! While the basic concepts may be true, the sermon focuses primarily on Gods wrath and very little on the rest of God...which is a LOT. If you read the Bible, you'll see glimpses of what He's talking about...but the message of the Bible is one of love, not wrath. The sermon has left a lot of people with an unbalanced view of God. And I agree..."People have been forcing upon others the fear of God unto others to convince and control them for hundreds of years." But the fact that this has happened does not make it right nor does it reflect on who God actually is. Sadly, Christians have misrepresented God for years.
As far as the "Why doesn't God Heal Amputees" thing, I'll respond to that one on the actual blog post as soon as I can. I need to anyway! I will say that I was glad they used Scripture because it shows that they've at least put some intellectual thought into it. But it's kind of like how I am with cars...I know enough to be dangerous. I know how to fix several things on the car, but I feel REALLY uncomfortable giving my opinion about what's wrong with a vehicle, because I just don't know enough. I can't pretend to be a mechanic when I don't know how the whole car works.
Post a Comment